Moderator: 3ne2nr Mods
Bia, I support Indians and their culture and do get nuff cuss on tuner for it.timelapse wrote:Hold this
https://www.nalis.gov.tt/resources/tt-content-guide/indian-arrival-day/
This
https://icdn.today/is-there-no-other-musical-instrument-indigenous-to-tt/#google_vignette
this
http://www.trinicenter.com/more/dhantaal.htm?fbclid=IwY2xjawH7Zq1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHSOJ8T_3Te9S4e9esmRP9MiX9ldqV6avA1x5VA1jQkhQINVtnD2raq0b5A_aem_39j--jQypzdeznVEHWO18Q
And this
https://www.guardian.co.tt/article-6.2.446445.9c3d8106df
pugboy wrote:lol trinidad killa is complete representation of our society
esp the part when he say every artiste does do the same(wrong) ting
Go easy on them timestimelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:When they going to add the Dhantaal? Seeing as though it was also invented here?
Look Sat Maharaj people reach! Always looking to downplay what the poor people invented.
You do not even know your own history. The Dhantal was NOT invented in T&T.
"The history of the dhantal can be traced back to the arrival of Indian indentured laborers in Trinidad and Tobago in the 19th century (McLeod, 2007). The instrument was brought over by the laborers and became an essential part of their religious and cultural practices.
Today, the dhantal is recognized as an important part of Trinidad and Tobago’s cultural heritage, and efforts have been made to preserve and promote the instrument (McLeod, 2007). "
https://trinidadianpercussion.wordpress.com/dhantal/
I will proudly accept the title of Sat Maharaj people, because the other people here will not even acknowledge the East Indian contributions to the country.
Even more blatant is the not so subtle disrespect in mis-pronouncing East Indian words, the complete butchering of what a roti is and so on.Even more evident is on social media where if Indo Caribbean foos are being highlighted ,theres always someone to complain about why is only Indo foods and not pelau,calalloo etc. Those who accustomed to holding the victim card of racism do not comprehend that they also can be racist.
As for both the sources you cited there, neither one can represent any conclusive evidence that the dhantal was not invented in Trinidad. The older country folks here will know the big steel pins that were used to tie cows,goats etc back in the day.If they were wagon pins or rail pins, I don't know.But these along with Horse shoes were the basis of the dhantal.Before the dhantal,they used large coins and a cutlass to achieve similar sounds.
timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:When they going to add the Dhantaal? Seeing as though it was also invented here?
Look Sat Maharaj people reach! Always looking to downplay what the poor people invented.
You do not even know your own history. The Dhantal was NOT invented in T&T.
"The history of the dhantal can be traced back to the arrival of Indian indentured laborers in Trinidad and Tobago in the 19th century (McLeod, 2007). The instrument was brought over by the laborers and became an essential part of their religious and cultural practices.
Today, the dhantal is recognized as an important part of Trinidad and Tobago’s cultural heritage, and efforts have been made to preserve and promote the instrument (McLeod, 2007). "
https://trinidadianpercussion.wordpress.com/dhantal/
I will proudly accept the title of Sat Maharaj people, because the other people here will not even acknowledge the East Indian contributions to the country.
Even more blatant is the not so subtle disrespect in mis-pronouncing East Indian words, the complete butchering of what a roti is and so on.Even more evident is on social media where if Indo Caribbean foos are being highlighted ,theres always someone to complain about why is only Indo foods and not pelau,calalloo etc. Those who accustomed to holding the victim card of racism do not comprehend that they also can be racist.
As for both the sources you cited there, neither one can represent any conclusive evidence that the dhantal was not invented in Trinidad. The older country folks here will know the big steel pins that were used to tie cows,goats etc back in the day.If they were wagon pins or rail pins, I don't know.But these along with Horse shoes were the basis of the dhantal.Before the dhantal,they used large coins and a cutlass to achieve similar sounds.
timelapse wrote:Hold this
https://www.nalis.gov.tt/resources/tt-content-guide/indian-arrival-day/
This
https://icdn.today/is-there-no-other-musical-instrument-indigenous-to-tt/#google_vignette
this
http://www.trinicenter.com/more/dhantaal.htm?fbclid=IwY2xjawH7Zq1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHSOJ8T_3Te9S4e9esmRP9MiX9ldqV6avA1x5VA1jQkhQINVtnD2raq0b5A_aem_39j--jQypzdeznVEHWO18Q
And this
https://www.guardian.co.tt/article-6.2.446445.9c3d8106df
It was not invented in Trinidad cause it is played by Fijian Indians that share the same culture is Trinidad, Guyana and Suriname Indians.bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:When they going to add the Dhantaal? Seeing as though it was also invented here?
Look Sat Maharaj people reach! Always looking to downplay what the poor people invented.
You do not even know your own history. The Dhantal was NOT invented in T&T.
"The history of the dhantal can be traced back to the arrival of Indian indentured laborers in Trinidad and Tobago in the 19th century (McLeod, 2007). The instrument was brought over by the laborers and became an essential part of their religious and cultural practices.
Today, the dhantal is recognized as an important part of Trinidad and Tobago’s cultural heritage, and efforts have been made to preserve and promote the instrument (McLeod, 2007). "
https://trinidadianpercussion.wordpress.com/dhantal/
I will proudly accept the title of Sat Maharaj people, because the other people here will not even acknowledge the East Indian contributions to the country.
Even more blatant is the not so subtle disrespect in mis-pronouncing East Indian words, the complete butchering of what a roti is and so on.Even more evident is on social media where if Indo Caribbean foos are being highlighted ,theres always someone to complain about why is only Indo foods and not pelau,calalloo etc. Those who accustomed to holding the victim card of racism do not comprehend that they also can be racist.
As for both the sources you cited there, neither one can represent any conclusive evidence that the dhantal was not invented in Trinidad. The older country folks here will know the big steel pins that were used to tie cows,goats etc back in the day.If they were wagon pins or rail pins, I don't know.But these along with Horse shoes were the basis of the dhantal.Before the dhantal,they used large coins and a cutlass to achieve similar sounds.
To be fair, it works both ways. Unfortunately, it is always noticeable that whenever any discussion of the steelpan arises, "Sat's People" (LOL) always try to ingratiate themselves into the discussion by raising the issues of indian musical instruments that were clearly NOT INVENTED in T&T.timelapse wrote:Hold this
https://www.nalis.gov.tt/resources/tt-content-guide/indian-arrival-day/
This
https://icdn.today/is-there-no-other-musical-instrument-indigenous-to-tt/#google_vignette
this
http://www.trinicenter.com/more/dhantaal.htm?fbclid=IwY2xjawH7Zq1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHSOJ8T_3Te9S4e9esmRP9MiX9ldqV6avA1x5VA1jQkhQINVtnD2raq0b5A_aem_39j--jQypzdeznVEHWO18Q
And this
https://www.guardian.co.tt/article-6.2.446445.9c3d8106df
You will notice that I referenced ACADEMIC sources and not internet websites. However, there is no evidence that the dhantal was invented in T&T - even after all that research was done.
bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:When they going to add the Dhantaal? Seeing as though it was also invented here?
Look Sat Maharaj people reach! Always looking to downplay what the poor people invented.
You do not even know your own history. The Dhantal was NOT invented in T&T.
"The history of the dhantal can be traced back to the arrival of Indian indentured laborers in Trinidad and Tobago in the 19th century (McLeod, 2007). The instrument was brought over by the laborers and became an essential part of their religious and cultural practices.
Today, the dhantal is recognized as an important part of Trinidad and Tobago’s cultural heritage, and efforts have been made to preserve and promote the instrument (McLeod, 2007). "
https://trinidadianpercussion.wordpress.com/dhantal/
I will proudly accept the title of Sat Maharaj people, because the other people here will not even acknowledge the East Indian contributions to the country.
Even more blatant is the not so subtle disrespect in mis-pronouncing East Indian words, the complete butchering of what a roti is and so on.Even more evident is on social media where if Indo Caribbean foos are being highlighted ,theres always someone to complain about why is only Indo foods and not pelau,calalloo etc. Those who accustomed to holding the victim card of racism do not comprehend that they also can be racist.
As for both the sources you cited there, neither one can represent any conclusive evidence that the dhantal was not invented in Trinidad. The older country folks here will know the big steel pins that were used to tie cows,goats etc back in the day.If they were wagon pins or rail pins, I don't know.But these along with Horse shoes were the basis of the dhantal.Before the dhantal,they used large coins and a cutlass to achieve similar sounds.
To be fair, it works both ways. Unfortunately, it is always noticeable that whenever any discussion of the steelpan arises, "Sat's People" (LOL) always try to ingratiate themselves into the discussion by raising the issues of indian musical instruments that were clearly NOT INVENTED in T&T.timelapse wrote:Hold this
https://www.nalis.gov.tt/resources/tt-content-guide/indian-arrival-day/
This
https://icdn.today/is-there-no-other-musical-instrument-indigenous-to-tt/#google_vignette
this
http://www.trinicenter.com/more/dhantaal.htm?fbclid=IwY2xjawH7Zq1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHSOJ8T_3Te9S4e9esmRP9MiX9ldqV6avA1x5VA1jQkhQINVtnD2raq0b5A_aem_39j--jQypzdeznVEHWO18Q
And this
https://www.guardian.co.tt/article-6.2.446445.9c3d8106df
You will notice that I referenced ACADEMIC sources and not internet websites. However, there is no evidence that the dhantal was invented in T&T - even after all that research was done.
Indians have made their own marks and in the Caribbean.timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:When they going to add the Dhantaal? Seeing as though it was also invented here?
Look Sat Maharaj people reach! Always looking to downplay what the poor people invented.
You do not even know your own history. The Dhantal was NOT invented in T&T.
"The history of the dhantal can be traced back to the arrival of Indian indentured laborers in Trinidad and Tobago in the 19th century (McLeod, 2007). The instrument was brought over by the laborers and became an essential part of their religious and cultural practices.
Today, the dhantal is recognized as an important part of Trinidad and Tobago’s cultural heritage, and efforts have been made to preserve and promote the instrument (McLeod, 2007). "
https://trinidadianpercussion.wordpress.com/dhantal/
I will proudly accept the title of Sat Maharaj people, because the other people here will not even acknowledge the East Indian contributions to the country.
Even more blatant is the not so subtle disrespect in mis-pronouncing East Indian words, the complete butchering of what a roti is and so on.Even more evident is on social media where if Indo Caribbean foos are being highlighted ,theres always someone to complain about why is only Indo foods and not pelau,calalloo etc. Those who accustomed to holding the victim card of racism do not comprehend that they also can be racist.
As for both the sources you cited there, neither one can represent any conclusive evidence that the dhantal was not invented in Trinidad. The older country folks here will know the big steel pins that were used to tie cows,goats etc back in the day.If they were wagon pins or rail pins, I don't know.But these along with Horse shoes were the basis of the dhantal.Before the dhantal,they used large coins and a cutlass to achieve similar sounds.
To be fair, it works both ways. Unfortunately, it is always noticeable that whenever any discussion of the steelpan arises, "Sat's People" (LOL) always try to ingratiate themselves into the discussion by raising the issues of indian musical instruments that were clearly NOT INVENTED in T&T.timelapse wrote:Hold this
https://www.nalis.gov.tt/resources/tt-content-guide/indian-arrival-day/
This
https://icdn.today/is-there-no-other-musical-instrument-indigenous-to-tt/#google_vignette
this
http://www.trinicenter.com/more/dhantaal.htm?fbclid=IwY2xjawH7Zq1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHSOJ8T_3Te9S4e9esmRP9MiX9ldqV6avA1x5VA1jQkhQINVtnD2raq0b5A_aem_39j--jQypzdeznVEHWO18Q
And this
https://www.guardian.co.tt/article-6.2.446445.9c3d8106df
You will notice that I referenced ACADEMIC sources and not internet websites. However, there is no evidence that the dhantal was invented in T&T - even after all that research was done.
I not fighting down the steelpan,is just that Indo Trinidadians are always being ignored when it comes to the country's history.
The ppl who benefit are the financiars, they have the same financiars like Junior Sammy for example, a government spends the most money in the election year.Les Bain wrote:So government and opposition approved this redesign; when does this item of high national importance move forward, and what's the estimated cost to taxpayers?
16 cycles wrote:previous coat of arms helped to educate nation on the 'beginning' ...
steelpan might just be a reflection of how we invented something and someone else commercialized it - like an inside joke to a missed opportunity...
zoom rader wrote:Who really gives a fvck on what's on the coat of arms.
Does this improve your lives?
Are you better off if this symbol is changed every Monday morning?
Together we aspire, together we achieve has done nothing for Trinidad but play propaganda mind games.
As Max said Trinis are still nasty and disgusting people
They haven't rioted yettimelapse wrote:zoom rader wrote:Who really gives a fvck on what's on the coat of arms.
Does this improve your lives?
Are you better off if this symbol is changed every Monday morning?
Together we aspire, together we achieve has done nothing for Trinidad but play propaganda mind games.
As Max said Trinis are still nasty and disgusting people
We will have to pay to get documents changed AGAIN
timelapse wrote:I not fighting down the steelpan,is just that Indo Trinidadians are always being ignored when it comes to the country's history.
timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:When they going to add the Dhantaal? Seeing as though it was also invented here?
Look Sat Maharaj people reach! Always looking to downplay what the poor people invented.
You do not even know your own history. The Dhantal was NOT invented in T&T.
"The history of the dhantal can be traced back to the arrival of Indian indentured laborers in Trinidad and Tobago in the 19th century (McLeod, 2007). The instrument was brought over by the laborers and became an essential part of their religious and cultural practices.
Today, the dhantal is recognized as an important part of Trinidad and Tobago’s cultural heritage, and efforts have been made to preserve and promote the instrument (McLeod, 2007). "
https://trinidadianpercussion.wordpress.com/dhantal/
I will proudly accept the title of Sat Maharaj people, because the other people here will not even acknowledge the East Indian contributions to the country.
Even more blatant is the not so subtle disrespect in mis-pronouncing East Indian words, the complete butchering of what a roti is and so on.Even more evident is on social media where if Indo Caribbean foos are being highlighted ,theres always someone to complain about why is only Indo foods and not pelau,calalloo etc. Those who accustomed to holding the victim card of racism do not comprehend that they also can be racist.
As for both the sources you cited there, neither one can represent any conclusive evidence that the dhantal was not invented in Trinidad. The older country folks here will know the big steel pins that were used to tie cows,goats etc back in the day.If they were wagon pins or rail pins, I don't know.But these along with Horse shoes were the basis of the dhantal.Before the dhantal,they used large coins and a cutlass to achieve similar sounds.
To be fair, it works both ways. Unfortunately, it is always noticeable that whenever any discussion of the steelpan arises, "Sat's People" (LOL) always try to ingratiate themselves into the discussion by raising the issues of indian musical instruments that were clearly NOT INVENTED in T&T.timelapse wrote:Hold this
https://www.nalis.gov.tt/resources/tt-content-guide/indian-arrival-day/
This
https://icdn.today/is-there-no-other-musical-instrument-indigenous-to-tt/#google_vignette
this
http://www.trinicenter.com/more/dhantaal.htm?fbclid=IwY2xjawH7Zq1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHSOJ8T_3Te9S4e9esmRP9MiX9ldqV6avA1x5VA1jQkhQINVtnD2raq0b5A_aem_39j--jQypzdeznVEHWO18Q
And this
https://www.guardian.co.tt/article-6.2.446445.9c3d8106df
You will notice that I referenced ACADEMIC sources and not internet websites. However, there is no evidence that the dhantal was invented in T&T - even after all that research was done.
I not fighting down the steelpan,is just that Indo Trinidadians are always being ignored when it comes to the country's history.
bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:I not fighting down the steelpan,is just that Indo Trinidadians are always being ignored when it comes to the country's history.
Not necessarily so. But I understand where you are coming from.
Meanwhile, who saw this yesterday?
Read and understand where Trump was coming from all those years ago. We damn lucky he did not follow through.
Trini man recalls gifting steelpan to US President Trump
He said Trump’s curiosity shifted to the steelpan. “He was fascinated. He even asked if the steel drum was patented. I told him it was patented in Trinidad, but he wanted to know if it was patented in the US.”
https://www.guardian.co.tt/news/trini-m ... 49feb5fcc7
viedcht wrote:Steelpan used to be a mostly black folk thing, hardly saw indos playing pan. Go look at the old ttt footage and point out the indos playing pan.
It echoes a togetherness that those Trinis with Slavery roots will always gravitate towards. Politicians using it to manipulate people's emotions, to support this simple change, and Our continued divide is wrong.
paid_influencer wrote:bluefete wrote:timelapse wrote:I not fighting down the steelpan,is just that Indo Trinidadians are always being ignored when it comes to the country's history.
Not necessarily so. But I understand where you are coming from.
Meanwhile, who saw this yesterday?
Read and understand where Trump was coming from all those years ago. We damn lucky he did not follow through.
Trini man recalls gifting steelpan to US President Trump
He said Trump’s curiosity shifted to the steelpan. “He was fascinated. He even asked if the steel drum was patented. I told him it was patented in Trinidad, but he wanted to know if it was patented in the US.”
https://www.guardian.co.tt/news/trini-m ... 49feb5fcc7
the gpan patent was in 2008 and patent lasts 20 years
so from 2028 gpan is fair game for anyone interested
16 cycles wrote:previous coat of arms helped to educate nation on the 'beginning' ...
steelpan might just be a reflection of how we invented something and someone else commercialized it - like an inside joke to a missed opportunity...
Alpha_2nr wrote:16 cycles wrote:previous coat of arms helped to educate nation on the 'beginning' ...
steelpan might just be a reflection of how we invented something and someone else commercialized it - like an inside joke to a missed opportunity...
A missed opportunity, like how the patent for steelpan production is held by the US?
Instead of by us/Trinidad/a trini, who were the inventors of said instrument?
What has Pan trinbago been doing, anybody held accountable for such. Which party had the majority of leadership years since independence, we all know who is to blame here.Dizzy28 wrote:Alpha_2nr wrote:16 cycles wrote:previous coat of arms helped to educate nation on the 'beginning' ...
steelpan might just be a reflection of how we invented something and someone else commercialized it - like an inside joke to a missed opportunity...
A missed opportunity, like how the patent for steelpan production is held by the US?
Instead of by us/Trinidad/a trini, who were the inventors of said instrument?
There is no patent for steelpan production being held by anyone in the US.
There are patents for electronic synthesizer pans, for the metallurgy behind new pans and for particular pieces of equipment for production.
https://patents.google.com/?q=(steelpan+production)&oq=steelpan+production
As a taxpayer we should be concerned that after tens of millions of dollars were spent on the G Pan and PHI Pan patents they expire in two years time and no real commercialization and subsequent monetization has happened. Waste of money in this country that by now is accustomed to wasting money.
I remember going to a training years ago done by a guy from Ireland who headed R&D for a number of European FMCG companies and the guy said if you don't intend to go to market quickly its makes no sense filing a patent.
Return to “Ole talk and more Ole talk”
Users browsing this forum: Duane 3NE 2NR, Google Adsense [Bot] and 17 guests