Flow
Flow
Flow
TriniTuner.com  |  Latest Event:  

Forums

PNM in Gov't (2020-2025)

this is how we do it.......

Moderator: 3ne2nr Mods

User avatar
The_Honourable
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 10515
Joined: June 14th, 2009, 3:45 pm
Location: Together We Conspire, Together We Deceive

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby The_Honourable » May 2nd, 2024, 6:43 pm

Habit7 wrote:I dont know how race got into this. Because when kids backflipping and frolicking in the same sewage water in floods in UNC constituencies it is just as bad.

In the last elections, both Laventilles and POS constituencies had less than 50% turnout. Meaning that only the diehard PNMites came out to vote, the majority of the constituents don't vote. These constituencies are ripe for the taking but the UNC is failing to expand beyond its base. You can't cuss Laventillians, tell them they are dumb for supporting PNM, tell them they are all criminals, lock them up in an SoE, racially despise them and then a few months before the election choose a nobody and say we love you, please vote for us. The same minority keeps electing PNM but the UNC is offering little alternative yet wants to win by default.

PNM do them good and PNM do them bad, but they still have self-respect. The majority will stay home and not vote but don't expect to pappyshow them and get their vote. UNC or some other 3rd party can win Laventille if they show them respect and present viable alternatives to what PNM does. But pointing and laughing at Laventille will still have you crying on election night at UNC HQ.


Nice try about "unc constituencies" but nah. Last time I checked beetham voted for pnm win or lose, pnm in government for 8 years, and they in sewage water. Your flex is that pnm give them housing LOL.

UNC has campaigned in both Laventille and POS in the past. The constituents who voted overwhelmingly choose the pnm. When there was alternative third-party options such as NNV, LOVE, ILP, PEP, other parties plus independents in the past, they still choose the pnm.

So some choosing to stay home instead of voting other parties while the diehards vote the pnm who don't have to fight for their vote? In my book, they like it so and they will continue to like it so for another fifty years. But say what... at least dey have dey lil housing so "we should be grateful and thank the lord for small mercies"... while enduring sewage water, poor infrastructure, poverty and crime.

As zoom say...

matr1x
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 8247
Joined: February 25th, 2017, 7:46 am

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby matr1x » May 2nd, 2024, 7:03 pm

Of course Habit7 had to bring race into it

User avatar
wing
punchin NOS
Posts: 2777
Joined: December 17th, 2008, 6:57 pm

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby wing » May 2nd, 2024, 7:15 pm

16 cycles wrote:https://guardian.co.tt/news/auditor-general-sends-legal-letter-to-imbert-retract-blatantly-false-comments-6.2.1988458.263cbc195f

Ramdass in the pre-action protocol letter, which was obtained by Guardian Media, explained that two months after the Ministry of Finance (MoF) submitted the public accounts on January 31, 2024, she was advised that they had made a massive error whereby the ministry was now claiming that the Government’s revenue was understated by over $3 billion—to be exact $3,379,777,908.

The Auditor General indicated that the ministry wanted to amend the national accounts to reflect this higher revenue figure.

However, she said the ministry admitted that whilst it could account for some of this money, the sum of $780,499,791.27 could not be accounted for.

$ billions spent without documentation

Auditor Generals Report:

May 30, 2014



Several Government Ministries, including the Ministry of Finance, lack documentation to justify multi-million dollar expenses, the Auditor General's Report on Trinidad and Tobago's public accounts for Government's financial year 2013 (October 1, 2012 to September 30, 2013) has shown.

The worst offenders were the Ministry of Environment and Water Resources, the Ministry of Science and Technology, and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Not only did the Ministry of Environment and Water Resources fail to provide documents to support three payments totalling $266,569,000, it was not transparent with documents or answers to questions asked by the Auditor General.

The Ministry of Science and Technology failed to provide documents to the Auditor General for $19.3 million.

"In contravention of the Auditor General's right of access to documents on demand, critical records/documents such aas project files, contracts, bills, quotations, completion certificates, progress reports or status reports were not produced for audit. As a result, the validity of payments made totalling $19,300,000 on nine projects, the status of completion of each and adherence to relevant terms and conditions could not be ascertained," the report noted.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs failed to provide documents for 40 vouchers for contract employees valued at $6.1 million.

The report, dated April 29, 2014 and signed by Auditor General Sharon Ottley, also raised concerns about overpayments by ministries, lack of documentation to support contracted workers by the state and lack of proper accounting management by officers in charge of protecting the public purse.

There was also failure in many instances to respond to requests for more expenditure information, the Auditor General's report stated.

The state of internal audit functions in the Ministries and Departments "remains a matter of grave concern as in prior years", noted Ottley in her annual report.

She noted that the examination of records and documents showed that in many instances there was non-compliance with financial instructions, financial regulations and other financial directives while reports on appropriation accounts did not match what was produced for examination during the audit.

"The audit revealed numerous instances at various Ministries/Departments where Financial Regulations and Instructions as discussed at paragraph 1.6 continue to be disregarded. A pervasive need was identified for training of staff of Ministries and Departments in accounting regulations and procedures with a view to enhancing accountability and good governance," she said.

She noted that there are examples of "weaknesses in the system of internal control, as well as non-compliance with legislative requirements and/or financial directives" and a general lack of proper maintenance of the relevant subsidiary books and records.

"There were numerous instances were documents were requested for audit purposes were not produced. This represents a serious breach both of the Auditor General's constitutional and legal right to access to all documents relating to the Public Accounts and of financial and accountability requirements," she noted.

Recurring Offences

Contract Employees

Payments to contact employees, from information received from 28 permanent secretaries, totaled $415,836,835.32. That sum was paid to 3,450 persons employed in contract positions during the financial year ended September 30, 2013.

"The audit highlighted that duly executed contracts were not produced for several of those officers and as such the various terms of engagement could not be verified," it said.

The Trinidad and Tobago Police Service had the most contracted workers with 547; the Ministry of National Security with 423; the Ministry of Health with 391; and the Ministry of Finance and Economy with 321.

"As in the prior year, the examination of contract employment revealed that in many instances, terms and conditions approved by the Chief Personnel Officer (CPO) and/or signed contracts were not seen. In response to the observations raised accounting officers have indicated that matters are with the personnel department for action," the report said. (See Table 1)

Inventory Control

During the period 2009 to 2013, Government spent $2.2 billion in inventory.

But there were also cases of theft and losses reported.

For the financial year 2013, there were 42 cases of thefts and losses of state property totaling $301,408.10. There were 23 cases under $5,000 for a total value of $38,180.49 and 19 cases in excess of $5,000 totalling $263,227.61.

The Ministry of Education had 16 cases under $5,000 totalling $27,275. and nine cases totaling $74,790.85.

The Ministry of Food Production had four cases of theft totaling $126,785.85.

Lease Agreements

Signed lease agreements were not produced for audit for certain properties for which rental payments were made.

The Ministry of the Attorney General did not provide leases for five properties that had amounted to monthly rentals of $961,745.00.

The Environmental Commission did not provide a lease for its offices, which had been $106,777.50 and reduced to $66,527.50.

The Ministry of Tobago Development did not provide leases for four properties amounting to $596,103.65 a month.

Overpayments

The Auditor General noted that overpayments continue to be a major concern since they result in time and other resources being spent on accounting, recovery, reporting and auditing as well as, at times, emotional factors involved in the recovery process.

The report noted that a comparison of information presented in the Notes to the Appropriation Accounts of Ministries/Departments with the records of the Auditor General's Department revealed that with respect to certain Ministries/Departments reports were not received in the Auditor General's Department in several instances. A number of cases were also noted where the information presented in the Appropriation Accounts differed from that reported to the Auditor General.

(See Table 2)

Ministry of Finance and the Economy

• From a sample of 211 vouchers examined, evidence was not seen that in four Divisions, quotations were obtained for the purchase of items on the 'open market' in 44 instances with a total value of $1,790,178.36. This contravenes Financial Regulation (Stores) 31 as well as Central Tenders Board Circular Memorandum CTB: 4/2/6 Vol. 1 dated July 26, 2004.

• During the period reviewed of October 2012 to March 2013, amounts totalling $3,555,541.55 were paid to one provider for security services ($1,389,065.05) and for janitorial services ($2,166,496.50). Contract agreements were not seen. These payments also exceeded the Permanent Secretary's authorised expenditure limit of $1,000,000. The approval of the Central Tenders Board for the provision of these services was not seen.

• From a sample of 15 vouchers selected for Other Contracted Services, two vouchers totalling $974,625 were not supported by original invoices.

• Financial Instruction 108(4) which requires the Accounting Officer to "personally countersign vouchers covering transactions affected in previous years" was not seen to be followed in five instances for payments to one provider totalling $3,357,224.33.

Customs and Excise Division

• Two cheques dated September 25, 2013 and which totalled $795,000 for the purchase of three motor vehicles were seen on hand during the audit exercise in December 2013. The voucher was signed indicating receipt of the vehicles. However, there was no evidence that the vehicles had been received and taken into inventory. There was therefore a breach of Financial Regulation 71(1). In the circumstances these cheques should have been cancelled at the end of the financial year 30th September, 2013.

The following documents requested for audit purposes were not provided:

1.Vouchers for the months of January 2013 and September 2013 in respect to expenditure totalling $7,950,543.80;

2. Thirty-four vouchers totalling $5,814,577.66 from the sample selected for testing; schedules of accounts for five vouchers totalling $3,921,914.65, and

3.Cabinet approval for the execution of the project titled Infrastructure Upgrade of the Container Examination Station (CES) at Port of Spain.

The non-production of documents for audit not only breaches Financial Instruction 43 and Financial Regulation 8(l) but denies the Auditor General's legal and constitutional right of access.

Ministry of Food Production

• A review of a sample of 15 payments totalling $251,781.51 for Materials and Supplies revealed that proper procurement procedures were not followed in that Bonded Contractors were not used where applicable, neither were 3 quotations obtained for 'open market' purchases.

• Inventory records show that 290 vehicles are owned by the Ministry; however Vehicle Registers necessary to record the existence, location and status of vehicles were not seen to exist either at the Head Office or at 3 of the 11 outstations sampled.

• Two amounts of $14,250 were seen to be paid to one supplier on two different invoices for the same service performed on the same date.

• A Register of Contracts as required by Financial Regulation 129 (1) was not produced. As a result, the completeness of information relating to contracts not yet completed at Note 2.l ii shown as $946,599.50 could not be verified.

Ministry of Health

• A review of a sample of 34 payments totalling $135,332,981.58 revealed that invoices were not committed in the Vote Book as required by Financial Regulations 66 and 67 to allow for prudent cash management.

• From the sample reviewed, one payment voucher for $1,290,167.14 was not provided for audit.

• Documents required to verify the validity of expenditure of $770,611 for optometry equipment were not produced for audit.

• During a physical verification exercise, it was noted that 21 items valued at $197,163.82 from a sample of 51 items purchased during the year did not bear marks of identification as Government property in accordance with Financial Regulation (Stores) 55.

Ministry of Transport

• Documents to support a payment of $13,000,000 shown as Contribution towards Deficit on Coastal Steamers were not produced.

• The Overpayment Register necessary to monitor recovery and to determine balances outstanding was not seen to be up to date at the time of audit.

• A formal contract for works valued at $5,651,390 was not provided for audit purposes.

• Payments totalling $211,499 for the Supply and Installation of Emergency Lights were incorrectly charged to this vote. In addition, supporting documents were not provided.

Ministry of

Foreign Affairs

The following documents were also not provided:

• Cabinet approval for amounts totalling $1,530,171.72 paid to three sports ambassadors and Schedules of Accounts for 3 of these payments totalling $557,049.12

• Daily Abstracts of Payments for the period July to September 2013

• Invoices to support 3 payments totalling $82,217.00 to an office supplies company

• Two contracts for security services for which payments of $2,212,712.02 were seen to be made up to August, 2013 to the relevant entities. As a result of the above observations, related expenditure was not verified.

"Non-production of documents for audit represents a serious breach both of the Auditor General's constitutional and legal right of access to all documents relating to the Public Accounts and of financial and accountability requirements. Financial Instruction 43 states, "All vouchers, paid cheques and other relevant documents shall on request for audit examination be made available to the Auditor General or his nominee," the report noted.

"The internal controls were weak in that there was no segregation of duties. One officer was responsible for all aspects of receipts, deposits, payments, purchasing, custody of inventory items and maintenance of accounting and inventory records. Further, evidence of proper oversight by the certifying officer was not seen," it said.

Brussels Embassy

• Prior approval of the Treasury as required by Financial Regulation 20(2) for a non-permanent, non-pensionable officer to be an authorised signatory to the Mission's bank account was not produced.

• Bank deposit slips requested for the month of September, 2013 were reported to have been shredded and as a result were not presented.

• Approval from the Minister of Finance was not seen for the variation of established procedures related to non-maintenance of certain records in the transition to online banking.

• Records to support payments such as receipts, debit advices, direct transfers and other transaction slips were not provided.

Ministry of the

Environment

and Water Resources

• Documents to support three payments totalling $266,569,000 being Refunds to Water and Sewerage Authority Re Water Improvement Rate were not produced contrary to Financial Regulation 8(l) and the Auditor General's constitutional and legal right of access to all documents.

• From a sample of five vouchers selected, supporting documents were not seen for two items purchased under Minor Equipment while quotations were not seen for any of the items purchased. Physical verification of items could not be performed due to the absence of the storekeeper on the day of the audit visit.

Caroni Swamp

Management Project

• A commitment of $546,250 as shown on the Expenditure Statement for Development Programme was not seen to be recorded in the Vote Book. In addition, the Cabinet Minute and other project documents were not produced as requested.

Expenditure Control

• A review of a sample of 16 vouchers for Other Contracted Services revealed the under-mentioned issues.

Duplicate Payments

• Duplicate payments of $127,006.60 were seen to be paid to one contractor, the second payment being supported mainly by photocopied documents of the first. Evidence of Internal Audit certification was seen on the second voucher.

Unauthorised

Payments

• The approved spending limit of $50,000.00 was seen to be exceeded for ten payments totalling $6,874,159.21 (for amounts ranging from $261,898.79 to $970,538.18). Authorisation by the accounting officer was not seen.

Maintenance of

Expenditure Records

• Information was not seen to be properly recorded on Schedules of Accounts in accordance with Financial Instruction 27 in several instances. While these were subsequently corrected, it is important to note that proper and timely maintenance of accounting records is a key factor in expenditure control.

Ministry of Science

and Technology

• In contravention of the Auditor General's right of access to documents on demand, critical records/documents such as project files, contracts, bills, quotations, completion certificates, progress reports or status reports were not produced for audit. As a result, the validity of payments made totalling $19,300,000 on nine projects, the status of completion of each and adherence to relevant terms and conditions could not be ascertained.

• The Schedule of Accounts relating to an adjustment of a cancelled cheque for $4,000,000 was also not presented.

• Payment vouchers were not seen to be supported by relevant documents such as contract agreements or invoices from contractors.

• Cheque numbers and dates were not disclosed on payment vouchers totalling $2,974,699.75 and the related Schedules of Accounts as required by financial directives.

Consequently the audit trail was adversely affected, the report stated.

User avatar
sMASH
TunerGod
Posts: 25627
Joined: January 11th, 2005, 4:30 am

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby sMASH » May 2nd, 2024, 7:21 pm

How amour say he couldn't advise imburt and auditor general?
Wasn't he the same one that represented ish and Steve against trinidad and Tobago, then represented trinidad and Tobago against ish and Steve?

User avatar
wing
punchin NOS
Posts: 2777
Joined: December 17th, 2008, 6:57 pm

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby wing » May 2nd, 2024, 7:23 pm

sMASH wrote:How amour say he couldn't advise imburt and auditor general?
Wasn't he the same one that represented ish and Steve against trinidad and Tobago, then represented trinidad and Tobago against ish and Steve?
Why don't you just go to Gaza and fight for Hamas, because you are not serving any purpose here.

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 2nd, 2024, 7:58 pm

The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:I dont know how race got into this. Because when kids backflipping and frolicking in the same sewage water in floods in UNC constituencies it is just as bad.

In the last elections, both Laventilles and POS constituencies had less than 50% turnout. Meaning that only the diehard PNMites came out to vote, the majority of the constituents don't vote. These constituencies are ripe for the taking but the UNC is failing to expand beyond its base. You can't cuss Laventillians, tell them they are dumb for supporting PNM, tell them they are all criminals, lock them up in an SoE, racially despise them and then a few months before the election choose a nobody and say we love you, please vote for us. The same minority keeps electing PNM but the UNC is offering little alternative yet wants to win by default.

PNM do them good and PNM do them bad, but they still have self-respect. The majority will stay home and not vote but don't expect to pappyshow them and get their vote. UNC or some other 3rd party can win Laventille if they show them respect and present viable alternatives to what PNM does. But pointing and laughing at Laventille will still have you crying on election night at UNC HQ.


Nice try about "unc constituencies" but nah. Last time I checked beetham voted for pnm win or lose, pnm in government for 8 years, and they in sewage water. Your flex is that pnm give them housing LOL.

UNC has campaigned in both Laventille and POS in the past. The constituents who voted overwhelmingly choose the pnm. When there was alternative third-party options such as NNV, LOVE, ILP, PEP, other parties plus independents in the past, they still choose the pnm.

So some choosing to stay home instead of voting other parties while the diehards vote the pnm who don't have to fight for their vote? In my book, they like it so and they will continue to like it so for another fifty years. But say what... at least dey have dey lil housing so "we should be grateful and thank the lord for small mercies"... while enduring sewage water, poor infrastructure, poverty and crime.

As zoom say...

Firstly you are extrapolating a sewer problem in one location in Beetham to be affecting the entire constituency. The history of Beetham from colonial times was that it was a swamp that poor ppl would squat in. It was PNM that developed it, put streets, drainage, utilities, proper housing, schools and other govt services. But because their inherently high water table and location as drainage for the entire area, they are prone to sewage issues. This might be news to you but this has been so for decades. Why UNC didn’t fix it? But because one area they have an issue, you believe they should run into the arms of UNC.

Well it for the UNC to take. Only like 45% of ppl voted there. Of that 45% PNM won the majority. So there is like 70% of ppl for the UNC to take. You want to blame PNM for poverty and crime as if the ppl are not responsible for that themselves. But then again that is the same condescending attitude they get from UNC, hence their failure to get votes there.

User avatar
zoom rader
TunerGod
Posts: 30521
Joined: April 22nd, 2003, 12:39 pm
Location: Grand Cayman

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby zoom rader » May 2nd, 2024, 8:07 pm

wing wrote:
sMASH wrote:How amour say he couldn't advise imburt and auditor general?
Wasn't he the same one that represented ish and Steve against trinidad and Tobago, then represented trinidad and Tobago against ish and Steve?
Why don't you just go to Gaza and fight for Hamas, because you are not serving any purpose here.
Doh beat wing

Pnm Victory 2025

Mmoney607
punchin NOS
Posts: 3375
Joined: April 1st, 2021, 9:21 am

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Mmoney607 » May 2nd, 2024, 8:14 pm

sMASH wrote:How amour say he couldn't advise imburt and auditor general?
Wasn't he the same one that represented ish and Steve against trinidad and Tobago, then represented trinidad and Tobago against ish and Steve?

That's a good one :D

Mmoney607
punchin NOS
Posts: 3375
Joined: April 1st, 2021, 9:21 am

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Mmoney607 » May 2nd, 2024, 8:16 pm

A state company admits under parliamentary oath that a minister instructed them to award a contract to a certain supplier. Police supposed to question them people first thing tomorrow morning.

User avatar
The_Honourable
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 10515
Joined: June 14th, 2009, 3:45 pm
Location: Together We Conspire, Together We Deceive

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby The_Honourable » May 2nd, 2024, 10:41 pm

Habit7 wrote:
The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:I dont know how race got into this. Because when kids backflipping and frolicking in the same sewage water in floods in UNC constituencies it is just as bad.

In the last elections, both Laventilles and POS constituencies had less than 50% turnout. Meaning that only the diehard PNMites came out to vote, the majority of the constituents don't vote. These constituencies are ripe for the taking but the UNC is failing to expand beyond its base. You can't cuss Laventillians, tell them they are dumb for supporting PNM, tell them they are all criminals, lock them up in an SoE, racially despise them and then a few months before the election choose a nobody and say we love you, please vote for us. The same minority keeps electing PNM but the UNC is offering little alternative yet wants to win by default.

PNM do them good and PNM do them bad, but they still have self-respect. The majority will stay home and not vote but don't expect to pappyshow them and get their vote. UNC or some other 3rd party can win Laventille if they show them respect and present viable alternatives to what PNM does. But pointing and laughing at Laventille will still have you crying on election night at UNC HQ.


Nice try about "unc constituencies" but nah. Last time I checked beetham voted for pnm win or lose, pnm in government for 8 years, and they in sewage water. Your flex is that pnm give them housing LOL.

UNC has campaigned in both Laventille and POS in the past. The constituents who voted overwhelmingly choose the pnm. When there was alternative third-party options such as NNV, LOVE, ILP, PEP, other parties plus independents in the past, they still choose the pnm.

So some choosing to stay home instead of voting other parties while the diehards vote the pnm who don't have to fight for their vote? In my book, they like it so and they will continue to like it so for another fifty years. But say what... at least dey have dey lil housing so "we should be grateful and thank the lord for small mercies"... while enduring sewage water, poor infrastructure, poverty and crime.

As zoom say...

Firstly you are extrapolating a sewer problem in one location in Beetham to be affecting the entire constituency. The history of Beetham from colonial times was that it was a swamp that poor ppl would squat in. It was PNM that developed it, put streets, drainage, utilities, proper housing, schools and other govt services. But because their inherently high water table and location as drainage for the entire area, they are prone to sewage issues. This might be news to you but this has been so for decades. Why UNC didn’t fix it? But because one area they have an issue, you believe they should run into the arms of UNC.

Well it for the UNC to take. Only like 45% of ppl voted there. Of that 45% PNM won the majority. So there is like 70% of ppl for the UNC to take. You want to blame PNM for poverty and crime as if the ppl are not responsible for that themselves. But then again that is the same condescending attitude they get from UNC, hence their failure to get votes there.


You are a clown

"A" sewer problem? there were sewer problems all over beetham which you just admitted. Well look at that, pnm have them in a swamp. Poor utilities, poor drainage, substandard housing, failing infrastructure, and what government services?

UNC this and UNC that. Where did I say they should run in the arms of the UNC? I advocate for demanding more for their votes and exercise voting for other parties if pnm and unc not working for them. By your stats, 45% of the people should demand more for their vote while 55% should actually vote.

That has been so for decades? Guess who they allowing to ride their back for decades.

Dey like it so.

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 3rd, 2024, 7:28 am

The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:
The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:I dont know how race got into this. Because when kids backflipping and frolicking in the same sewage water in floods in UNC constituencies it is just as bad.

In the last elections, both Laventilles and POS constituencies had less than 50% turnout. Meaning that only the diehard PNMites came out to vote, the majority of the constituents don't vote. These constituencies are ripe for the taking but the UNC is failing to expand beyond its base. You can't cuss Laventillians, tell them they are dumb for supporting PNM, tell them they are all criminals, lock them up in an SoE, racially despise them and then a few months before the election choose a nobody and say we love you, please vote for us. The same minority keeps electing PNM but the UNC is offering little alternative yet wants to win by default.

PNM do them good and PNM do them bad, but they still have self-respect. The majority will stay home and not vote but don't expect to pappyshow them and get their vote. UNC or some other 3rd party can win Laventille if they show them respect and present viable alternatives to what PNM does. But pointing and laughing at Laventille will still have you crying on election night at UNC HQ.


Nice try about "unc constituencies" but nah. Last time I checked beetham voted for pnm win or lose, pnm in government for 8 years, and they in sewage water. Your flex is that pnm give them housing LOL.

UNC has campaigned in both Laventille and POS in the past. The constituents who voted overwhelmingly choose the pnm. When there was alternative third-party options such as NNV, LOVE, ILP, PEP, other parties plus independents in the past, they still choose the pnm.

So some choosing to stay home instead of voting other parties while the diehards vote the pnm who don't have to fight for their vote? In my book, they like it so and they will continue to like it so for another fifty years. But say what... at least dey have dey lil housing so "we should be grateful and thank the lord for small mercies"... while enduring sewage water, poor infrastructure, poverty and crime.

As zoom say...

Firstly you are extrapolating a sewer problem in one location in Beetham to be affecting the entire constituency. The history of Beetham from colonial times was that it was a swamp that poor ppl would squat in. It was PNM that developed it, put streets, drainage, utilities, proper housing, schools and other govt services. But because their inherently high water table and location as drainage for the entire area, they are prone to sewage issues. This might be news to you but this has been so for decades. Why UNC didn’t fix it? But because one area they have an issue, you believe they should run into the arms of UNC.

Well it for the UNC to take. Only like 45% of ppl voted there. Of that 45% PNM won the majority. So there is like 70% of ppl for the UNC to take. You want to blame PNM for poverty and crime as if the ppl are not responsible for that themselves. But then again that is the same condescending attitude they get from UNC, hence their failure to get votes there.


You are a clown

A sewer problem? there were sewer problems all over beetham which you just admitted. Well look at that, pnm have them in a swamp. Poor utilities, poor drainage, substandard housing, failing infrastructure, and what government services?

UNC this and UNC that. Where did I say they should run in the arms of the UNC? I advocate for demanding more for their votes and exercising voting for other parties if pnm and unc not working for them. By your stats, 45% of the people should demand more for their vote while 55% should actually vote.

That has been so for decades? Guess who they allowing to ride their back for decades.

Dey like it so.

You are displaying why there are not votes for other than the PNM. You don't care about the Beethamites, they are just pawns in your politics in which you can denigrate and broad bush them without knowing anything about Beetham. Nobody is living in a swamp, PNM took a colonial shanty town that was in a swamp and built a neighbourhood with infrastructure. If they have a central sewage system that has a leak somewhere, then the leak has to be fixed. But it is still infrastructure. But you are crying they don't have proper infrastructure, they tell you that? The leak happened in an HDC housing area where they are building further facilities for them, but are you crying that they have poor infrastructure, drainage and govt services? I remember sitting in traffic after PNM came back in power on a Saturday because Hinds decided to change every collapsed culvert under Beetham Hwy to provide better drainage. But a UNC activist kicked water on him and we all laughed. Because heavy is the head that wears the crown. https://tt.loopnews.com/content/culvert ... -completed

Beetham is one neighbourhood in the larger constituency of Laventille West. 9310 ppl voted for PNM in 2020 out of 25,585 eligible voters, in other words 36%. But you think a sewage leak on 24th Street in Beetham should paint all Laventille West a dumb voters in the clutches of PNM who should have a perfect central sewage system but because they don't, "Dey like it so." 36% is enough for you to share the same sentiment of the UNC and broad brush them. Apparently you know what infrastructure, drainage, utilities and govt services Beethamites lack and what everybody else is getting. You want to drink bush tea for their fever. You know that the residents most affected by the leak will still ram their X by the Balisier. Why? Because you can judge ppl based on their address, not as individuals.

BTW
WASA completes work on Beetham sewer leak
20240502

Work has been completed on the leak which has caused much distress to residents of Beetham Gardens in recent times, an advisory from the Water and Sewerage Authority has confirmed.

“Works to remedy overflows around 24th Street, Beetham Gardens are now complete and the area fully sanitized,” WASA reports.

According to the WASA advisory, indiscriminate dumping of garbage contributed to the misery experienced by the residents.

“In the process of pump down activity to reduce the overflows, investigations confirmed that this event was in fact caused by the removal of sewer line end caps,” WASA says, “and further exacerbated by indiscriminate dumping of garbage, oils and grease into the sewer system connected to the HDC building, located in the vicinity of 24th Street. The Authority’s wastewater team immediately removed the garbage—inclusive of oil and grease—and replaced the compromised sewer line.”

“This line replacement was done as a temporary measure to bypass the existing cleanout and mitigate the potential for overflow at this connection,” WASA explains. “Manholes upstream of the building sewers were inspected to confirm carrying capacity as a further mitigation measure. In addition to this, tankers will continue to be deployed daily to assist in preventing potential overflows.”

The Authority is urging all citizens to desist from disposing garbage, oils and grease into wastewater systems, “as this practice can compromise the sewer lines, bringing extreme discomfort to residents connected to these facilities.”
https://guardian.co.tt/news/wasa-comple ... 914c98f9b9

User avatar
shake d livin wake d dead
TunerGod
Posts: 33218
Joined: July 20th, 2009, 1:25 pm
Location: all over

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby shake d livin wake d dead » May 3rd, 2024, 10:50 am

Open ah whole new hospital and the service remains the same
Attachments
20240503_104511.png

Mmoney607
punchin NOS
Posts: 3375
Joined: April 1st, 2021, 9:21 am

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Mmoney607 » May 3rd, 2024, 11:01 am

shake d livin wake d dead wrote:Open ah whole new hospital and the service remains the same

Yea boy, but what we go do? We absolutely can't bring back kamla

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 3rd, 2024, 11:37 am

We could return to being a colony of Britain as some have suggested



About 2yrs ago a close relative of mine broke a bone at home and an ambulance took them to Mt Hope. After a couple of hours of X-rays and lying and doing nothing, my family had to make a decision. Stay and wait for days or weeks to get surgery to repair the bone or go private. We decided to be discharged against medical advice and went to SAPH. In a few days, the surgery was done and the relative was sent home.

The reality is once you have a public service it will be oversubscribed and have long wait times. The same occurs in the UK's NHS and Canada's healthcare system too. Worse yet, ours is underfunded with salaried ppl paying a health surcharge of $42 a month with many other non-salaried ppl not paying along with avoiding other taxes. Health Surcharge only earns like $300M a yr while for the last 10yrs we got like 5 new hospitals at an average price of $1B each. New hospitals are great but once the system is overwhelmed, it is a nicer building to wait in.

My relative was not rich but invested a little money in a group health plan in a credit union (about $100). Though I had to dip into my savings to pay for the surgery the majority of the money was reimbursed by the insurance (the surgery cost $30,000). You can cuss PNM or UNC but the result will be the same. Make sure you have a little health insurance so that you are not too dependent on the public healthcare system. Because they are working with a triage system and unless you are at the point of death, you will have to wait until they can deal with your nonlife-threatening issue

User avatar
wing
punchin NOS
Posts: 2777
Joined: December 17th, 2008, 6:57 pm

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby wing » May 3rd, 2024, 12:44 pm

Mmoney607 wrote:
shake d livin wake d dead wrote:Open ah whole new hospital and the service remains the same

Yea boy, but what we go do? We absolutely can't bring back kamla
Kamla is a nurse? Doctor?

User avatar
shake d livin wake d dead
TunerGod
Posts: 33218
Joined: July 20th, 2009, 1:25 pm
Location: all over

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby shake d livin wake d dead » May 3rd, 2024, 12:46 pm

Ahhh yes, the all over the wurlllllll counter. Then again, Bobby head say to have faith in the system....but he always abroad for medical check ups

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 3rd, 2024, 1:28 pm

So because you suffering from myopia, everybody else should suffer too? The President of the US does check ups in a clinic in Wyoming or he does it at the top military hospital in Washington DC? You stay there and cry PNM and UNC. If ppl have money let them spent it. There is no way our island with 1.5M ppl can have the comprehensive healthcare of a city serving 10s of millions with deep pockets to back it.

And since “all over the wurlllllll” is invalid, consider our crime rates as normal, if not perfect. Since we can’t compare metrics with other countries then who is to say we aren’t in nirvana right now?

User avatar
The_Honourable
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 10515
Joined: June 14th, 2009, 3:45 pm
Location: Together We Conspire, Together We Deceive

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby The_Honourable » May 3rd, 2024, 2:58 pm

Habit7 wrote:
The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:
The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:I dont know how race got into this. Because when kids backflipping and frolicking in the same sewage water in floods in UNC constituencies it is just as bad.

In the last elections, both Laventilles and POS constituencies had less than 50% turnout. Meaning that only the diehard PNMites came out to vote, the majority of the constituents don't vote. These constituencies are ripe for the taking but the UNC is failing to expand beyond its base. You can't cuss Laventillians, tell them they are dumb for supporting PNM, tell them they are all criminals, lock them up in an SoE, racially despise them and then a few months before the election choose a nobody and say we love you, please vote for us. The same minority keeps electing PNM but the UNC is offering little alternative yet wants to win by default.

PNM do them good and PNM do them bad, but they still have self-respect. The majority will stay home and not vote but don't expect to pappyshow them and get their vote. UNC or some other 3rd party can win Laventille if they show them respect and present viable alternatives to what PNM does. But pointing and laughing at Laventille will still have you crying on election night at UNC HQ.


Nice try about "unc constituencies" but nah. Last time I checked beetham voted for pnm win or lose, pnm in government for 8 years, and they in sewage water. Your flex is that pnm give them housing LOL.

UNC has campaigned in both Laventille and POS in the past. The constituents who voted overwhelmingly choose the pnm. When there was alternative third-party options such as NNV, LOVE, ILP, PEP, other parties plus independents in the past, they still choose the pnm.

So some choosing to stay home instead of voting other parties while the diehards vote the pnm who don't have to fight for their vote? In my book, they like it so and they will continue to like it so for another fifty years. But say what... at least dey have dey lil housing so "we should be grateful and thank the lord for small mercies"... while enduring sewage water, poor infrastructure, poverty and crime.

As zoom say...

Firstly you are extrapolating a sewer problem in one location in Beetham to be affecting the entire constituency. The history of Beetham from colonial times was that it was a swamp that poor ppl would squat in. It was PNM that developed it, put streets, drainage, utilities, proper housing, schools and other govt services. But because their inherently high water table and location as drainage for the entire area, they are prone to sewage issues. This might be news to you but this has been so for decades. Why UNC didn’t fix it? But because one area they have an issue, you believe they should run into the arms of UNC.

Well it for the UNC to take. Only like 45% of ppl voted there. Of that 45% PNM won the majority. So there is like 70% of ppl for the UNC to take. You want to blame PNM for poverty and crime as if the ppl are not responsible for that themselves. But then again that is the same condescending attitude they get from UNC, hence their failure to get votes there.


You are a clown

A sewer problem? there were sewer problems all over beetham which you just admitted. Well look at that, pnm have them in a swamp. Poor utilities, poor drainage, substandard housing, failing infrastructure, and what government services?

UNC this and UNC that. Where did I say they should run in the arms of the UNC? I advocate for demanding more for their votes and exercising voting for other parties if pnm and unc not working for them. By your stats, 45% of the people should demand more for their vote while 55% should actually vote.

That has been so for decades? Guess who they allowing to ride their back for decades.

Dey like it so.

You are displaying why there are not votes for other than the PNM. You don't care about the Beethamites, they are just pawns in your politics in which you can denigrate and broad bush them without knowing anything about Beetham. Nobody is living in a swamp, PNM took a colonial shanty town that was in a swamp and built a neighbourhood with infrastructure. If they have a central sewage system that has a leak somewhere, then the leak has to be fixed. But it is still infrastructure. But you are crying they don't have proper infrastructure, they tell you that? The leak happened in an HDC housing area where they are building further facilities for them, but are you crying that they have poor infrastructure, drainage and govt services? I remember sitting in traffic after PNM came back in power on a Saturday because Hinds decided to change every collapsed culvert under Beetham Hwy to provide better drainage. But a UNC activist kicked water on him and we all laughed. Because heavy is the head that wears the crown. https://tt.loopnews.com/content/culvert ... -completed

Beetham is one neighbourhood in the larger constituency of Laventille West. 9310 ppl voted for PNM in 2020 out of 25,585 eligible voters, in other words 36%. But you think a sewage leak on 24th Street in Beetham should paint all Laventille West a dumb voters in the clutches of PNM who should have a perfect central sewage system but because they don't, "Dey like it so." 36% is enough for you to share the same sentiment of the UNC and broad brush them. Apparently you know what infrastructure, drainage, utilities and govt services Beethamites lack and what everybody else is getting. You want to drink bush tea for their fever. You know that the residents most affected by the leak will still ram their X by the Balisier. Why? Because you can judge ppl based on their address, not as individuals.

BTW
WASA completes work on Beetham sewer leak
20240502

Work has been completed on the leak which has caused much distress to residents of Beetham Gardens in recent times, an advisory from the Water and Sewerage Authority has confirmed.

“Works to remedy overflows around 24th Street, Beetham Gardens are now complete and the area fully sanitized,” WASA reports.

According to the WASA advisory, indiscriminate dumping of garbage contributed to the misery experienced by the residents.

“In the process of pump down activity to reduce the overflows, investigations confirmed that this event was in fact caused by the removal of sewer line end caps,” WASA says, “and further exacerbated by indiscriminate dumping of garbage, oils and grease into the sewer system connected to the HDC building, located in the vicinity of 24th Street. The Authority’s wastewater team immediately removed the garbage—inclusive of oil and grease—and replaced the compromised sewer line.”

“This line replacement was done as a temporary measure to bypass the existing cleanout and mitigate the potential for overflow at this connection,” WASA explains. “Manholes upstream of the building sewers were inspected to confirm carrying capacity as a further mitigation measure. In addition to this, tankers will continue to be deployed daily to assist in preventing potential overflows.”

The Authority is urging all citizens to desist from disposing garbage, oils and grease into wastewater systems, “as this practice can compromise the sewer lines, bringing extreme discomfort to residents connected to these facilities.”
https://guardian.co.tt/news/wasa-comple ... 914c98f9b9



"But you are crying they don't have proper infrastructure, they tell you that?"


Stench of neglect

YET AGAIN, there’s a problem with the sewage system at Beetham Gardens.

Yet again, the authorities have been too slow to respond.

And yet again, politicians have been found wanting.

For two weeks, residents of 24th Street have been enduring the intolerable. Raw sewage has been overflowing, entering yards and homes. If a child’s ball ends up in a canal, they might follow it and bring back sickness.

“We are humans as well,” said president of the community council, Joel Lee, on April 30. “We know it’s because of the area we live in that we are being neglected. If this was Westmoorings, Trincity or Valsayn, these issues would be resolved long time.”

We wish we could contradict such assertions, but the facts make that difficult.

It was only three years ago, in August 2021, that a sinkhole caused by a ruptured sewer formed in the area. More than a week reportedly elapsed before the Water and Sewage Authority (WASA) mobilised a team.

But by January 2022, the matter was still unresolved; desperate residents staged a fiery protest.

Contacted then for comment, WASA chairman Ravindra Nanga pleaded for a little more patience and apologised for the delay. It took months for repairs to be completed.

WASA this week said the current problem – which some residents say dates to 2019 – stems from demolition activity, exposed sewer lines, missing end caps, and recent rainfall forcing water into the sewer system.

The authority hasn’t been able to say how soon it will be fixed.

There’s no doubt aging infrastructure, all over the country, poses a challenge. Much of this infrastructure is no longer fit for purpose. And there are increasing pressures stemming from climate change.

But why should ordinary citizens bear the burden of all this? Why does the State, with all its resources, consistently fail to deal with and plan for these contingencies?

Mr Nanga last month, yet again, asked people to “hold strain” on the separate issue of WASA-created potholes; a new MoU with Lake Asphalt T&T Ltd was signed.

Will WASA officials ask 24th Street to have more patience, too?

Meanwhile, someone with seemingly little patience for scrutiny, Laventille West MP Fitzgerald Hinds, when contacted about the situation this week, said, “I only heard about it on Monday. But I was in the Beetham on Sunday. Tell your editors to write that.”

The cynical view that politicians only do walkabouts at elections or for optics is fuelled, in part, by the fact that many do not acknowledge “representation” as a wider exercise.

Needed now is not splashy pappyshow, but effective liaising with constituents, local government officials and the relevant Cabinet ministers to help address the situation unfolding right under the MP’s nose.

https://newsday.co.tt/2024/05/03/stench-of-neglect/


36% of Laventille West vote pnm while the remaining 64% for the most part lahaying with other political options on the table?

DEY. LIKE. IT. SO.

User avatar
The_Honourable
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 10515
Joined: June 14th, 2009, 3:45 pm
Location: Together We Conspire, Together We Deceive

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby The_Honourable » May 3rd, 2024, 3:02 pm

Habit7 wrote:So because you suffering from myopia, everybody else should suffer too? The President of the US does check ups in a clinic in Wyoming or he does it at the top military hospital in Washington DC? You stay there and cry PNM and UNC. If ppl have money let them spent it. There is no way our island with 1.5M ppl can have the comprehensive healthcare of a city serving 10s of millions with deep pockets to back it.

And since “all over the wurlllllll” is invalid, consider our crime rates as normal, if not perfect. Since we can’t compare metrics with other countries then who is to say we aren’t in nirvana right now?


He within the United States getting checkups not so?

“all over the wurlllllll” is pnmites favorite excuse to deflect from pnm incompetence.

When POS flood this rainy season, you will hear "buh buh buh... dat happening all over the wurlllllll... yuh cyah stop daaaatt"

A bunch ah pnm YAP.

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 3rd, 2024, 3:57 pm

The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:
The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:
The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:I dont know how race got into this. Because when kids backflipping and frolicking in the same sewage water in floods in UNC constituencies it is just as bad.

In the last elections, both Laventilles and POS constituencies had less than 50% turnout. Meaning that only the diehard PNMites came out to vote, the majority of the constituents don't vote. These constituencies are ripe for the taking but the UNC is failing to expand beyond its base. You can't cuss Laventillians, tell them they are dumb for supporting PNM, tell them they are all criminals, lock them up in an SoE, racially despise them and then a few months before the election choose a nobody and say we love you, please vote for us. The same minority keeps electing PNM but the UNC is offering little alternative yet wants to win by default.

PNM do them good and PNM do them bad, but they still have self-respect. The majority will stay home and not vote but don't expect to pappyshow them and get their vote. UNC or some other 3rd party can win Laventille if they show them respect and present viable alternatives to what PNM does. But pointing and laughing at Laventille will still have you crying on election night at UNC HQ.


Nice try about "unc constituencies" but nah. Last time I checked beetham voted for pnm win or lose, pnm in government for 8 years, and they in sewage water. Your flex is that pnm give them housing LOL.

UNC has campaigned in both Laventille and POS in the past. The constituents who voted overwhelmingly choose the pnm. When there was alternative third-party options such as NNV, LOVE, ILP, PEP, other parties plus independents in the past, they still choose the pnm.

So some choosing to stay home instead of voting other parties while the diehards vote the pnm who don't have to fight for their vote? In my book, they like it so and they will continue to like it so for another fifty years. But say what... at least dey have dey lil housing so "we should be grateful and thank the lord for small mercies"... while enduring sewage water, poor infrastructure, poverty and crime.

As zoom say...

Firstly you are extrapolating a sewer problem in one location in Beetham to be affecting the entire constituency. The history of Beetham from colonial times was that it was a swamp that poor ppl would squat in. It was PNM that developed it, put streets, drainage, utilities, proper housing, schools and other govt services. But because their inherently high water table and location as drainage for the entire area, they are prone to sewage issues. This might be news to you but this has been so for decades. Why UNC didn’t fix it? But because one area they have an issue, you believe they should run into the arms of UNC.

Well it for the UNC to take. Only like 45% of ppl voted there. Of that 45% PNM won the majority. So there is like 70% of ppl for the UNC to take. You want to blame PNM for poverty and crime as if the ppl are not responsible for that themselves. But then again that is the same condescending attitude they get from UNC, hence their failure to get votes there.


You are a clown

A sewer problem? there were sewer problems all over beetham which you just admitted. Well look at that, pnm have them in a swamp. Poor utilities, poor drainage, substandard housing, failing infrastructure, and what government services?

UNC this and UNC that. Where did I say they should run in the arms of the UNC? I advocate for demanding more for their votes and exercising voting for other parties if pnm and unc not working for them. By your stats, 45% of the people should demand more for their vote while 55% should actually vote.

That has been so for decades? Guess who they allowing to ride their back for decades.

Dey like it so.

You are displaying why there are not votes for other than the PNM. You don't care about the Beethamites, they are just pawns in your politics in which you can denigrate and broad bush them without knowing anything about Beetham. Nobody is living in a swamp, PNM took a colonial shanty town that was in a swamp and built a neighbourhood with infrastructure. If they have a central sewage system that has a leak somewhere, then the leak has to be fixed. But it is still infrastructure. But you are crying they don't have proper infrastructure, they tell you that? The leak happened in an HDC housing area where they are building further facilities for them, but are you crying that they have poor infrastructure, drainage and govt services? I remember sitting in traffic after PNM came back in power on a Saturday because Hinds decided to change every collapsed culvert under Beetham Hwy to provide better drainage. But a UNC activist kicked water on him and we all laughed. Because heavy is the head that wears the crown. https://tt.loopnews.com/content/culvert ... -completed

Beetham is one neighbourhood in the larger constituency of Laventille West. 9310 ppl voted for PNM in 2020 out of 25,585 eligible voters, in other words 36%. But you think a sewage leak on 24th Street in Beetham should paint all Laventille West a dumb voters in the clutches of PNM who should have a perfect central sewage system but because they don't, "Dey like it so." 36% is enough for you to share the same sentiment of the UNC and broad brush them. Apparently you know what infrastructure, drainage, utilities and govt services Beethamites lack and what everybody else is getting. You want to drink bush tea for their fever. You know that the residents most affected by the leak will still ram their X by the Balisier. Why? Because you can judge ppl based on their address, not as individuals.

BTW
WASA completes work on Beetham sewer leak
20240502

Work has been completed on the leak which has caused much distress to residents of Beetham Gardens in recent times, an advisory from the Water and Sewerage Authority has confirmed.

“Works to remedy overflows around 24th Street, Beetham Gardens are now complete and the area fully sanitized,” WASA reports.

According to the WASA advisory, indiscriminate dumping of garbage contributed to the misery experienced by the residents.

“In the process of pump down activity to reduce the overflows, investigations confirmed that this event was in fact caused by the removal of sewer line end caps,” WASA says, “and further exacerbated by indiscriminate dumping of garbage, oils and grease into the sewer system connected to the HDC building, located in the vicinity of 24th Street. The Authority’s wastewater team immediately removed the garbage—inclusive of oil and grease—and replaced the compromised sewer line.”

“This line replacement was done as a temporary measure to bypass the existing cleanout and mitigate the potential for overflow at this connection,” WASA explains. “Manholes upstream of the building sewers were inspected to confirm carrying capacity as a further mitigation measure. In addition to this, tankers will continue to be deployed daily to assist in preventing potential overflows.”

The Authority is urging all citizens to desist from disposing garbage, oils and grease into wastewater systems, “as this practice can compromise the sewer lines, bringing extreme discomfort to residents connected to these facilities.”
https://guardian.co.tt/news/wasa-comple ... 914c98f9b9



"But you are crying they don't have proper infrastructure, they tell you that?"


Stench of neglect

YET AGAIN, there’s a problem with the sewage system at Beetham Gardens.

Yet again, the authorities have been too slow to respond.

And yet again, politicians have been found wanting.

For two weeks, residents of 24th Street have been enduring the intolerable. Raw sewage has been overflowing, entering yards and homes. If a child’s ball ends up in a canal, they might follow it and bring back sickness.

“We are humans as well,” said president of the community council, Joel Lee, on April 30. “We know it’s because of the area we live in that we are being neglected. If this was Westmoorings, Trincity or Valsayn, these issues would be resolved long time.”

We wish we could contradict such assertions, but the facts make that difficult.

It was only three years ago, in August 2021, that a sinkhole caused by a ruptured sewer formed in the area. More than a week reportedly elapsed before the Water and Sewage Authority (WASA) mobilised a team.

But by January 2022, the matter was still unresolved; desperate residents staged a fiery protest.

Contacted then for comment, WASA chairman Ravindra Nanga pleaded for a little more patience and apologised for the delay. It took months for repairs to be completed.

WASA this week said the current problem – which some residents say dates to 2019 – stems from demolition activity, exposed sewer lines, missing end caps, and recent rainfall forcing water into the sewer system.

The authority hasn’t been able to say how soon it will be fixed.

There’s no doubt aging infrastructure, all over the country, poses a challenge. Much of this infrastructure is no longer fit for purpose. And there are increasing pressures stemming from climate change.

But why should ordinary citizens bear the burden of all this? Why does the State, with all its resources, consistently fail to deal with and plan for these contingencies?

Mr Nanga last month, yet again, asked people to “hold strain” on the separate issue of WASA-created potholes; a new MoU with Lake Asphalt T&T Ltd was signed.

Will WASA officials ask 24th Street to have more patience, too?

Meanwhile, someone with seemingly little patience for scrutiny, Laventille West MP Fitzgerald Hinds, when contacted about the situation this week, said, “I only heard about it on Monday. But I was in the Beetham on Sunday. Tell your editors to write that.”

The cynical view that politicians only do walkabouts at elections or for optics is fuelled, in part, by the fact that many do not acknowledge “representation” as a wider exercise.

Needed now is not splashy pappyshow, but effective liaising with constituents, local government officials and the relevant Cabinet ministers to help address the situation unfolding right under the MP’s nose.

https://newsday.co.tt/2024/05/03/stench-of-neglect/


36% of Laventille West vote pnm while the remaining 64% for the most part lahaying with other political options on the table?

DEY. LIKE. IT. SO.

Cool editorial, but as you read in the news article I posted the issue was resolved after it was discovered it was caused by the sewer line end caps being removed. You can't make the argument that they don't have proper infrastructure by citing the infrastructure of their central sewer system. That is an infrastructure that the majority of areas in T&T don't have. This incident was caused by the tampering and misuse of the infrastructure, not because of the lack of it. People have to take personal responsibility for their actions. Somebody stealing metal fittings can only be reported by the community, not crying out to govt for the consequences.

You still believe that a sewer leak on one street in Beetham should make everybody in Laventille West vote for some other party while not considering those who benefit from PNM policy in housing, trade & skill education, unemployment relief, their own functional sewer system and many others. You think Laventille West should vote in your interest and that they are too stupid to vote in their own interest. I believe they will disagree.

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 3rd, 2024, 4:04 pm

The_Honourable wrote:
Habit7 wrote:So because you suffering from myopia, everybody else should suffer too? The President of the US does check ups in a clinic in Wyoming or he does it at the top military hospital in Washington DC? You stay there and cry PNM and UNC. If ppl have money let them spent it. There is no way our island with 1.5M ppl can have the comprehensive healthcare of a city serving 10s of millions with deep pockets to back it.

And since “all over the wurlllllll” is invalid, consider our crime rates as normal, if not perfect. Since we can’t compare metrics with other countries then who is to say we aren’t in nirvana right now?


He within the United States getting checkups not so?

“all over the wurlllllll” is pnmites favorite excuse to deflect from pnm incompetence.

When POS flood this rainy season, you will hear "buh buh buh... dat happening all over the wurlllllll... yuh cyah stop daaaatt"

A bunch ah pnm YAP.



UNC YAP:
"Well, a lot of people is fearful and we trust in our government that we know that they have a full hand in this and we have seen the production of them in the past and now I am sure that they would come in Madras Road, St Helena Village and other parts of the environs to give food to give shelter to give to give beds to beds to people mattress..."

Mmoney607
punchin NOS
Posts: 3375
Joined: April 1st, 2021, 9:21 am

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Mmoney607 » May 3rd, 2024, 8:03 pm

Ria Taitt
17 hrs ago
Disturbing.

This is how chairman of the Public Accounts Committee Dave Tancoo yesterday described information that the then-minister of agriculture gave a “verbal instruction” to National Agricultural Marketing and Development Corporation (Namdevco) chairman Wayne Inniss to engage a particular provider to do the corporation’s strategic 2019-2021 plan.

The minister at the time was Clarence Rambharat.

At the PAC meeting, Tancoo said the corporation had indicated in its written submission that the method used to procure the services for the development of the plan was sole selective (tender) based on Section 12 of the act, which states that in the exercise of its powers and duties, the corporation shall comply with any special or general directions which may from time to time be given to it by the minister.

“Were any guidelines provided by any minister for the selection of this entity to do the strat(egic) plan?” Tancoo asked.

Inniss said: “Yes, we were directed by the honourable minister then to use the services of the person who did this job.”

“Now this is very interesting and disturbing at the same time because the law is there which ­facilitates this action. Can you advise whether that recommendation to use a particular provider was provided in writing?” Tancoo asked.

“I received a verbal instruction,” Inniss stated.

“So you are saying that as chairman, you received an instruction from a sitting Minister of Government who says you should use this provider as opposed to using another process, maybe selective tendering?” Tancoo asked.

Inniss said the provider was already doing work with the ministry, when it (the ministry) began seeking a consultant to do a strategic plan.

The person was paid $75,000 for the plan.

Tancoo said his point was whether Inniss felt that was an “unusual or inappropriate methodology for selecting any supplier of any service. A ministerial direction should only be given under specific types of circumstances”.

Noting such a service is provided by many providers, he asked whether Inniss felt this was a ­normal way of doing business.

“Given the circumstances of the time and the urgency of the requirement, yes it was,” Inniss replied.

In response to a question, Inniss said there had been no other request by a minister to engage any other provider for any other activity.

Tancoo asked Inniss whether he was aware that according to the Ministry of Finance Investment Division, “and I quote, sole selective tendering should only be used in rare and exceptional circumstan­ces” as it is “the least transparent form of tendering. That is from the Investment Division Procurement Practices and Public Procurement and Disposal.

“Respectfully, I cannot see how the selection of a provider for a service for which there are many providers nationally and internationally... how that could be defined as such... ‘rare and exceptional circumstances’.”

Asked whether Inniss suggested to the minister that a competitive tendering process be used, Inniss said since under the act the minister could give such a direction, there was “no need to engage him in any additional discussion”.

He added that the prevailing circumstances at the time required “urgent action” to get the strategic plan done.

Tancoo said it was the lack of foresight, rather than “urgency” since the corporation knew well beforehand that the 2015-2018 strategic plan was going to expire.

When asked for his perspective on the matter, the permanent secretary in the Ministry of Agriculture Farook Hosein said he could not be helpful in this matter because he didn’t have the information.

Tancoo said he was also concerned because the corporation was not looking to do a strategic plan for 2022-25 or 2026.

“(The year) 2022 is gone, 2023 is gone, 2024 is going. So we are now looking to do a strategic plan for a period which has already passed,” he said.

Asked for the name of the company that provided the 2019-2021 strategic plan, Inniss said it was Dr Zameer Mohammed.

Tancoo asked what Namdevco did in the period prior to 2022 to expedite the 2022-2025 strategic plan, “given that you have no strat plan from 2022 to the current period, but you saw an ‘urgency’ and took the instruction of a minister then from 2019”.

“I can’t answer that question,” Inniss said.

Asked why Namdevco did not go back to Dr Mohammed to do the 2022-2025 strategic plan before the expiry of the 2019-2021 plan, Inniss said the individual was welcome to respond to the invitation to tender.

Direct evidence of corruption by a pnm minister

16 cycles
3ne2nr Toppa Toppa
Posts: 5935
Joined: May 10th, 2003, 9:25 am

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby 16 cycles » May 4th, 2024, 6:47 am

16 cycles wrote:should the Att.Gen advise both Minister of Finance and Auditor General equally on lawful and constitutional obligations?


Got the ans from article in express...
Seems att.gen advised auditor gen to seek external advice as he was already advising min of finance.

pugboy
TunerGod
Posts: 29386
Joined: September 6th, 2003, 6:18 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby pugboy » May 4th, 2024, 7:49 am

so att gen is part of govt that is “we” and the aud gen is part of the govt that is “dem”

User avatar
wing
punchin NOS
Posts: 2777
Joined: December 17th, 2008, 6:57 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby wing » May 4th, 2024, 8:38 am

pugboy wrote:so att gen is part of govt that is “we” and the aud gen is part of the govt that is “dem”
The Auditor General is an independent officeholder. The government cannot interfere in its operations.

User avatar
wing
punchin NOS
Posts: 2777
Joined: December 17th, 2008, 6:57 pm

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby wing » May 5th, 2024, 7:25 am

An ‘absence of supporting documents’
At the centre of the Govt-Auditor General impasse...

The absence of documents to support the claim of the understatement of $2.59 billion in revenue for fiscal 2023 is at the centre of the impasse that has developed between the Government and the Auditor General, documents show.


The Auditor General received and considered the revised figures in the Amended Statement of Public Accounts for the financial year 2023 from the Ministry of Finance.


However, having considered the Ministry of Finance’s submission about the understatement of revenue to the tune of $2.59 billion, the Auditor General could not use these revised figures in her Report on the country’s finances because of the absence of supporting documents.

This scenario is gleaned from documents obtained by the Sunday Express. E-mails between the office of the Auditor General and the Ministry of Finance indicate the Auditor General did perform an audit of the Amended Statement of the Public Accounts for financial year 2023. Arrangements were made for the Auditor General’s team to go into the Inland Revenue Division and the Comptroller of Accounts to audit the amended Statement of the Public Accounts.

The e-mails show the officials of the Auditor General Department obtained security clearance to go to the Inland Revenue Division and the Comptroller of Accounts to facilitate the auditing of the Amended Statement of the Public Accounts.

The e-mails show the team that went to the Inland Revenue Division and the Comptroller of Accounts.

On Wednesday, April 17, 2024, at 10.16 a.m., Michelle Superville-Craigwell, Audit Executive 1 (Ag) of the Auditor General Department, wrote to permanent secretary S Taylor Lee Chee, seeking permission for the following officers to have access to the Inland Revenue Division and the Comptroller of Accounts “to audit the Statements resubmitted to the Auditor General dated April 16, 2024 for the period 17th April, 2024 to 19tht April”.

The officers from the Auditor General’s Department who were to have access to the Inland Revenue Division were Michelle Superville-Craigwell, Gail Tissoo and Corrise Belasco, while the officers who were to have access to the Comptroller of Accounts were Denise Jogee, Mukesh Belgie, Michelle Sooknanan-Ramnath, Trisha Abraham, Michelle Superville-Craigwell, Gail Tissoo and Corrise Belasco.

Attached to the e-mail was also a request for documents for audit examination, which the Auditor General had asked for but did not receive. The e-mail said reference was made to the Auditor General’s Circular No 4 of 2023- dated December 14, 2023- re: Letters of Representation in respect of the Appropriation Account, the Statement of Receipts and Disbursements and the Financial Statement of various Funds for the financial year ended December 30, 2023.

The e-mail stated: “The Auditor General has not received this letter for the initial submission of the Appropriation Account, the Statement of Receipts and Disbursements and the Financial Statement of various Fund under the purview of the Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Finance (Investment Division) (FN5), Comptroller of Accounts (FN1), Comptroller of Customs and Excise (FN3), Commissioner of Inland Revenue Division and Chairman of the Board (FN3) and the restated submission of the Statements on 16th April, 2024.”

While the initial e-mail was sent to PS Taylor Lee Chee, it was another permanent secretary (Ag)-Michelle Durham-Kissoon, who spearheaded the arrangements on behalf of the Ministry of Finance.

Durham-Kissoon, in an e-mail response to Superville-Craig dated the same day (April 17) at 10.50 a.m., stated: “Permission is granted (for the officers of the Auditor General Department) to access IRD (Inland Revenue Division) and the Comptroller of Accounts, Treasury to audit the Statements resubmitted to the Auditor General dated April 16, 2024, over the period 17th April, 2024 p.m to 19th April, 2024.”

Still on the same day, at 11.47 a.m., an e-mail from Sharon Boodoosingh, commissioner and chairman of the Inland Revenue Department, to Superville Craig stated that further to permanent secretary Michelle Durham-Kissoon’s e-mail response, “please note that as it relates to the IRD (Inland Revenue Division) we have made the necessary arrangements for security for access for yourself, Gail Tissoo and Corrise Belasco. Your point of contact will be Ms Gillian Lee Ag Accountant IV, so kindly liaise with her regarding your time of arrival today”.

Management letter:

Where are the

documents?

Less than one week after the Auditor General Department was given access to the Inland Revenue Division and the Comptroller of Accounts to facilitate the audit of the Amendment Statements of the Public Accounts, the Auditor General submitted a “management letter on the Amended Public Accounts of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago for the Financial Year 2023”, dated April 23, 2024, addressed to permanent secretary S Taylor Lee Chee, notifying her of the Auditor General’s findings. The letter, which was included in the Audited Report, was signed by the Assistant Auditor General Shiva Sinanan and submitted on April 24 to the Speaker of the House, President of the Senate and the Minister of Finance, along with the Auditor’s General Report. The 14-page management letter, in a nutshell, stated the Auditor’s General Department was not given any documentation to verify the amended figures in the Amended Statement of Revenue. (A management letter is a letter prepared by the auditor issued at the completion of the audit which discusses findings and recommendations for improvement in internal control, that were identified during the audit and were not required to be included in the Auditor’s report on internal control and other management issues.)

The management letter said that on March 28, 2024, the Ministry of Finance requested an amendment to the Statement of Revenue due to a variance of a material amount. On April 16, 2024, the Auditor General’s Department accepted one compact disk (CD) containing the amended Public Accounts of Trinidad and Tobago for the financial year 2023. During the period April 17 to 18, 2024, attempts were made to verify the changes recorded in the CD received.

The management letter said that with respect to the Statement of Revenue, under Taxes on Income and Profits the amount in the original statement (of the Public Accounts) was $27.82 billion, while the amount in the amended statement received on April 16, 2024, was $28.15 billion—a difference of $335.75 million. The “reason the amended figure could not be verified” was because “supporting documents for the amended figure were not provided”.

With respect to revenues from taxes on goods and services, the amount in the original statement was $5.856 billion, while the amount in the amended statement was $8.1 billion—a difference of $2.26 billion.

Giving a further breakdown, the management letter stated that for Revenue from individuals, the amount listed in the original statement was $5.4 billion, while the figure $5.78 billion was given in the amendment statement of public accounts, resulting in a difference of $330 million. The management letter stated “supporting documents for the amended figure were not provided”.

With respect to the business levy, the amount given in the original statement of the public accounts was $757.48 million, while the amount in the amended statement was $763.19 million—a difference of $5.7 million. This could not be verified because supporting documents for the amended figure were not provided, it said.

In the area of Value Added Tax, the letter stated that $4.35 billion was given as the amount of revenue obtained from VAT. The amended statement gave the amount as $6.613 billion—a difference of $2.26 billion. Again, it noted “supporting documents for [the] amended figure were not provided”.

The total amount of revenue in the original statement was given as $61,890,373,020.22, while the total amount of revenue in the amended statement was listed as $64,488,503,781.94—a difference was $2,598,130,761.72. This $2.59 billion increase in the Statement of Revenue could not be verified because “supporting documents for the amended figure were not provided”, the management letter said.

The inability to verify the Statement of Revenue also affected the verification of the amounts given in the amended Statement for the Overdraft (Exchequer Account)—the original amount was $50.3 billion, while the amended statement said it was $47.76 billion—a difference of ($2.59 billion); the figure listed in the Total liabilities—the original statement said it was $64.43 billion, while the amended figure was $61.8 billion—a difference of ($2.56 billion); and the figure listed in the Consolidated Fund—the original figure was ($50.3 billion), while the revised figure was ($47.7 billion) with the difference being $2.56 billion.

The management letter recommended the relevant documentation be provided to support the changes made in the amended financial statements. Under the heading “Observations”, the letter stated: “On 2024 March 28th, the Ministry of Finance requested an amendment on the Statement of Revenue due to a variance of a material amount of $3,379,777,908.00. At this date, $2,598,130,761.72 was reconciled (by the Ministry of Finance) leaving an unreconciled amount of $781,647,146.28. On April 9th, the Ministry of Finance indicated the reconciliation process was completed with a total reconciled variance of $2,599,278,188.73. This leaves an unreconciled amount of the original March figure of $780,499,719.27.”

The management letter recommended that the ministry explain if the figure of $780,499,719,27 has been reconciled or needs to be reconciled.

It concluded it would be appreciated if “you can let us have written comments on the findings, observations and recommendations contained in this letter which, it must be emphasised, deals only with those matters which have come to our attention. Please address your response to ‘The Auditor General’ at the address at the top of this first page of this letter”, it said.

bluefete
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 14685
Joined: November 12th, 2008, 10:56 pm
Location: POS

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby bluefete » May 5th, 2024, 9:54 am

Habit7 wrote:And since “all over the wurlllllll” is invalid, consider our crime rates as normal, if not perfect. Since we can’t compare metrics with other countries then who is to say we aren’t in nirvana right now?


Ah know yuh wukking hard fuh your PNM pay, eh, but oh gorsch man, Habit 7, REALLY?

User avatar
Habit7
TriniTuner 24-7
Posts: 12156
Joined: April 20th, 2009, 10:20 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Habit7 » May 5th, 2024, 3:58 pm

bluefete wrote:
Habit7 wrote:And since “all over the wurlllllll” is invalid, consider our crime rates as normal, if not perfect. Since we can’t compare metrics with other countries then who is to say we aren’t in nirvana right now?


Ah know yuh wukking hard fuh your PNM pay, eh, but oh gorsch man, Habit 7, REALLY?

So when you was talking chupidness like govt going to bundle sell private Niquan and public Petrotrin. You was doing that for free?

Somebody must have contributed for you to talk that nonsense.

daxt0r
I LUV THIS PLACE
Posts: 905
Joined: November 5th, 2009, 2:44 pm

Re: Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby daxt0r » May 5th, 2024, 4:10 pm

wing wrote:
pugboy wrote:so att gen is part of govt that is “we” and the aud gen is part of the govt that is “dem”
The Auditor General is an independent officeholder. The government cannot interfere in its operations.


You mean exactly like what abject failure tollum head did with PolSC and the merit list? and impsbutt did by giving himself tax breaks.
jeez boy d juice does hv allyuh dotish yes.

Mmoney607
punchin NOS
Posts: 3375
Joined: April 1st, 2021, 9:21 am

Re: PNM in Gov't

Postby Mmoney607 » May 5th, 2024, 4:24 pm

More of Rowley friends involved in criminal activity
Aluko Ato Warner, one of the sons of Tobago construction magnate Allan Warner, is among eight people charged in connection with an illegal quarrying operation in Wallerfield. Warner, sources confirmed, was arrested and charged following a raid at a Moonan Road quarry processing site on Thursday.

Advertisement

Return to “Ole talk and more Ole talk”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Duane 3NE 2NR, pugboy and 52 guests