Moderator: 3ne2nr Mods
If it was God's will anyway, then the prayer didn't do anything.Habit7 wrote:In 2008 I was living in Jamaica. Hurricanes had ravished Jamaica several times before (Ivan, Wilma, etc). When Gustav was approaching Jamaica, the predominantly Christian nation prayed and its track took a more northerly direction and was going to miss Jamaica with only some thunderstorms that night. The next morning the nation woke up in a frenzy scrambling to prepare because although the hurricane was passing Jamaica to the north, it doubled back and now was going to directly hit the heavy populated city of Kingston on the south coast. Many ppl lost their homes and their lives.
How does my anecdote reconcile with your reference of Robin Maharaj's anecdote?
Isaiah 45:7 The One forming light and creating darkness, Causing well-being and creating calamity; I am the LORD who does all these.
Christian prayer is for the will of God (Matthew 6:10). The will of God sometimes is to spare, sometimes it is to destroy. So prayer only diverts a natural disaster when it was God's will to divert it anyway.
As someone who has lived thru 2 category 4 hurricanes (Luis '95 & Lenny '99) and 3 category 3s and 3 storms...where my wife and I nearly lost our lives...trees, cars, entire houses and boats flying thru the air...plus at this moment in time battling cancer...I have to wonder what sort of thinking would prompt an individual to attribute the "choice to divert or allow" a disaster to God.Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:If it was God's will anyway, then the prayer didn't do anything.Habit7 wrote:Christian prayer is for the will of God (Matthew 6:10). The will of God sometimes is to spare, sometimes it is to destroy. So prayer only diverts a natural disaster when it was God's will to divert it anyway.
Habit7 wrote:Christian prayer is for the will of God (Matthew 6:10). The will of God sometimes is to spare, sometimes it is to destroy. So prayer only diverts a natural disaster when it was God's will to divert it anyway.
well if not God then who?V8 Boys wrote:As someone who has lived thru 2 category 4 hurricanes (Luis '95 & Lenny '99) and 3 category 3s and 3 storms...where my wife and I nearly lost our lives...trees, cars, entire houses and boats flying thru the air...plus at this moment in time battling cancer...I have to wonder what sort of thinking would prompt an individual to attribute the "choice to divert or allow" a disaster to God.Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:If it was God's will anyway, then the prayer didn't do anything.Habit7 wrote:Christian prayer is for the will of God (Matthew 6:10). The will of God sometimes is to spare, sometimes it is to destroy. So prayer only diverts a natural disaster when it was God's will to divert it anyway.
Really, are you gonna point out to us that in times past God allowed destruction to come upon his people and also diverted it at other times?
yes surely that was the case with HIS people...the Israelites.
But in case you missed the point....what determines in your mind whether any ONE country/people are HIS chosen people today?
Don't know if this logic was brought out already in this thread, but if a hurricane/quake/coconut destroys St Maarten but leaves Saba, Statia and Anguila...does that mean that God temporarily revoked his Passport with those 3 islands?
Is he a Trini but not a Vincentian, Tobagonian...etc?
Now don't go peltin the Holy Scriptures willy nilly in your response eh...I used clear, simple and common sense logic to highlight the idiocy of attributing improper actions or inaction to the Creator of every living thing.
Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:what then is the purpose of prayer?
some of that is contradictory but I meant in the context of praying for a natural disaster not to happen or for you to be saved from one.Country_Bookie wrote:Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:what then is the purpose of prayer?
Prayer is about changing yourself, so u can understand the will of God. Prayer teaches us humility, as no matter how powerful and mighty you might think you are, every one of us needs help from above sometime. Prayer is about being grateful, as everyone of us has received blessings that we know we did not deserve.
not really. the topic here is God regarding natural disasters considering we are in hurricane season and the recent earthquake.Habit7 wrote:This thread requires a merge before I go any further.
Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:If it was God's will anyway, then the prayer didn't do anything.Habit7 wrote:In 2008 I was living in Jamaica. Hurricanes had ravished Jamaica several times before (Ivan, Wilma, etc). When Gustav was approaching Jamaica, the predominantly Christian nation prayed and its track took a more northerly direction and was going to miss Jamaica with only some thunderstorms that night. The next morning the nation woke up in a frenzy scrambling to prepare because although the hurricane was passing Jamaica to the north, it doubled back and now was going to directly hit the heavy populated city of Kingston on the south coast. Many ppl lost their homes and their lives.
How does my anecdote reconcile with your reference of Robin Maharaj's anecdote?
Isaiah 45:7 The One forming light and creating darkness, Causing well-being and creating calamity; I am the LORD who does all these.
Christian prayer is for the will of God (Matthew 6:10). The will of God sometimes is to spare, sometimes it is to destroy. So prayer only diverts a natural disaster when it was God's will to divert it anyway.
what then is the purpose of prayer?
Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:not really. the topic here is God regarding natural disasters considering we are in hurricane season and the recent earthquake.Habit7 wrote:This thread requires a merge before I go any further.
Someone mentioned prayer and I asked if prayer can help to prevent a natural disaster and you said you believed the answer is no.
Don't see the need for a thread merge here so far. If there is something you mentioned in another thread that is relevant here then feel free to quote it and post the link.
a blind force cannot "intend", it does not have a conscience. Earthquakes do not intend to kill anyone unless you believe that they are created by a supernatural force to do just that.Habit7 wrote:Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:If it was God's will anyway, then the prayer didn't do anything.Habit7 wrote:In 2008 I was living in Jamaica. Hurricanes had ravished Jamaica several times before (Ivan, Wilma, etc). When Gustav was approaching Jamaica, the predominantly Christian nation prayed and its track took a more northerly direction and was going to miss Jamaica with only some thunderstorms that night. The next morning the nation woke up in a frenzy scrambling to prepare because although the hurricane was passing Jamaica to the north, it doubled back and now was going to directly hit the heavy populated city of Kingston on the south coast. Many ppl lost their homes and their lives.
How does my anecdote reconcile with your reference of Robin Maharaj's anecdote?
Isaiah 45:7 The One forming light and creating darkness, Causing well-being and creating calamity; I am the LORD who does all these.
Christian prayer is for the will of God (Matthew 6:10). The will of God sometimes is to spare, sometimes it is to destroy. So prayer only diverts a natural disaster when it was God's will to divert it anyway.
what then is the purpose of prayer?
Christians are supposed to pray the will of God to happen. There many things God has expressed as the will of God for Christians (this is vast and I will not got too much in depth of this). But for events and occurrences not spoken of specifically in the Bible such as disasters what is the will of God? God says He works "all things after the counsel of His will" Ephesians 1:11. So prayer is an effort where Christians can align themselves with God's will in diverting a disaster or align themselves with God's will in allowing the disaster. If their prayers went contrary to what occurred then they receive and further understanding that God is sovereign and we must submit to that.
In the book Jonah, Jonah was called to rise and go the wicked pagan Ninevites and cry out to them to repent lest God's judgement came upon them. Despite Jonah's best efforts, he did arrive and cried out to the Ninevites and they repented, disaster averted. However in Luke 13:1 some Jews while in the process of worshipping and offering sacrifices, were sought out by the Roman authorities and brutally killed. In one instance God spared wicked heathens, in another God allowed the killing of faithful Jews. Why did that happened, we don't know.
But when Jesus was asked if the men that were killed were more deserving than any other, Jesus said, "but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish" Luke 13:4,5. Whether you die from the earth opening up and swallowing you, or you die at 96 in your sleep, if you die without having repenting of your sins and trusting in Christ, your result will be the same, separation from God in punishment.
The answer for if prayer can help to prevent a natural disaster isn't as simple as yes or no, but if your are a naturalist a natural disaster should be welcomed with opened arms as a blind force than either intends to kill you are make you stronger. But if you are not consistent with your naturalism, a natural disaster scares you because your insignificant spark amongst many will soon be snuff out and you don't know if you are right that the supernatural doesn't exist.
Nature doesn't have a mind, but you believe in natural selection. The language is metaphorical, don't use it as a distraction.Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:a blind force cannot "intend", it does not have a conscience.
"We"? Do you acknowledge that there is a God?Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:If we should be praying the will of God to happen, when an earthquake, tsunami or hurricane kills thousands of people should we pray happy that God's will has happened?
natural selection does not require belief, it happens anyway.Habit7 wrote:Nature doesn't have a mind, but you believe in natural selection. The language is metaphorical, don't use it as a distraction.Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:a blind force cannot "intend", it does not have a conscience.
another distraction.Habit7 wrote:"We"? Do you acknowledge that there is a God?Duane 3NE 2NR wrote:If we should be praying the will of God to happen, when an earthquake, tsunami or hurricane kills thousands of people should we pray happy that God's will has happened?
I haven't read nor posted in the religion thread in a while, however when I read it I didn't notice at any time that:Habit7 wrote:This is why I wanted a merge with the Religion Thread. So we can catalogue the many times you attempt to bring some kind of 'gotcha' question and when it is soundly answered and your inconsistency is shown you go quiet until the next topic.
I think I have soundly answered your previous question but even in the subsequent one you are asking, there are presuppositions that are mentioned that needs to be dealt with first.
So please answer my questions too.
sharkman121 wrote:Doh beat up